SUBJECT:
CERTIFICATE
OF
APPROPRIATENESS
LOCATION:
1221 HERMOSA AVENUE - BIJOU THEATER BUILDING
APPLICANT:
CIM GROUP LLC
10960 WILSHIRE BOULEVARD LOS
ANGELES, CA 90024
Recommendation:
To direct staff as
deemed appropriate relative to issuing a Certificate of
Appropriateness for interior and exterior alterations to the
Bijou Building.
Background:
On April 27, 1999 the
City Council adopted Resolution Nos. 99-5980 and 99-5981
designating the Bijou Building a historic landmark pursuant
to Section 17.53.070 of the Historic Preservation Ordinance
and approving use of the Secretary of Interior Standards for
Building Rehabilitation in connection with the Historic
Preservation Ordinance. The applicant has submitted plans for
interior and exterior alterations to the building and staff
has referred them to the City’s preservation
consultant, Planning Consultants Research (PCR) for review.
(Please see Attachment No. 1). Seismic retro-fit of the
building is currently underway pursuant to Resolution No.
98-5940 and the review and approval of the project seismic
retrofit plans by PCR. PCR staff will coordinate with the
developer and City building inspectors and perform on-site
monitoring to verify that all construction work complies with
Secretary of the Interior Standards for the Treatment of
Historic Properties. The applicant is currently revising
plans to incorporate the recommendations of PCR, and staff
believes that with the corrections recommended by PCR, the
proposed project will conform to the requirements of the
Secretary’s Standards and the City’s Historic
Preservation Ordinance.
Analysis:
City staff, the
consultant, and the developer are working together to
implement the intent Historic Preservation Ordinance. The
proposed remodel of the Bijou Building includes seismic
retrofit (under previous permit) and renovation of the
building’s interior and exterior. The remodel project
will not add any floor area to the existing building. The
standard of review for the project is the Secretary of
Interior Standards for Treatment of Historic Properties and
the City’s Preservation Ordinance. The main focus of
the project according to PCR should be on retaining the
"existing character defining features" as a condition of
building permit approval. The building was previously
surveyed by PCR and a list of character defining features has
been prepared for the building. The proposed project involves
creating new tenant space and bringing the property into
compliance with the Building Code. PCR originally indicated
the need for several plan changes and clarifications prior to
issuance of a building permit, which are summarized
below:
-
The placement of
HVAC units on the roof may have potential visual impact
from Pier Avenue and the north elevation;
-
Relocation of the
trash enclosure within the Bijou property;
-
Inappropriate shape
and design of the proposed marquee and canopies on 13th
Street;
-
Any work that may
pose a threat to existing plaster details;
-
The amount of
existing foyer tile floor to remain;
-
Clarification
needed of the word "original" in reference to work
proposed on the mezzanine plan, and the north, south and
east elevations;
-
The use of two sets
of French doors, instead of the existing three sets of
double doors, for the foyer entry on the east
elevation;
-
Clarification
needed on what action is going to be taken toward the
existing fire escape ladders.
These issues have been
addressed on the proposed plans. Accessibility issues are
being examined as described below in Section 4
(Elevator).
Interior Alterations
1. Theater Area:
The theater area will
likely be converted to four retail tenant spaces fronting
on Hermosa Avenue and Thirteenth Street. The owner has not
provided a tenant improvement plan, however the current
approved plans include leveling of the existing theater
floor and four entries on Thirteenth Street. The Thirteenth
Street entries create tenant spaces ranging in width from
23 to 30 feet.
The foyer of the
theater area will be upgraded with several improvements
which includes the following: restoring the main archway
between the foyer and main theater area; relocation of
existing entry doors; reduction of the floor level to match
the floor level in the theater area; and removal of the
existing drop ceiling. Based on the concerns of PCR, there
are several columns and other plaster details that must be
preserved and restored as part of the work done. Because
there is existing tile work on the foyer floor, the plans
will indicate that a portion of the tile work will be
preserved and relocated to the front entry.
2. Bank Area:
The bank area will be
improved with new storefront windows and doors, which,
according to the developer, will match the original doors,
and windows. PCR is concerned with the plaster details on
the ceiling and walls of the bank area, since they are part
of the character defining features of the Bijou Building.
Any seismic retrofit or remodel work done in the bank area
will need to preserve the plaster details, and any lost or
damaged plaster details must be replaced.
The most recent use
of the bank area was as a retail establishment. The bank
area will most likely continue to be leased out as retail
space.
3. Office Areas:
The office areas
located on the 2
nd
and 3
rd
floors will be improved with new interior partitions
subject to future tenant improvement plans. The existing
windows are proposed to be cleaned, restored and painted to
their "original" condition. The term "original" is used
several times on the proposed plans and refers to the
proposed work which is consistent with the Secretary of
Interior Standards for Treatment of Historic Properties.
Also, the current condition of, and any proposed work on,
the existing fire escape ladders needs to be indicated
because of fire safety issues. The Uniform Building Code
indicates that two separate means of egress are required
for the second and third stories. Pursuant to Section 8-704
- Exception 1, of the State Historical Building Code, the
existing fire escapes shall be acceptable as one of the
required means of egress if they extend to the ground and
are easily negotiated, adequately signed, and in good
working order. Access to the fire escapes shall be by an
opening having a minimum width and height of 29 inches when
open, and the opening’s sill shall be no more than 30
inches above the adjacent floor, landing or approved step.
Thus, by meeting these conditions, the building will have
three acceptable means of egress.
4. Elevator:
The building must
comply with accessibility standards. The ADA requires an
elevator service a building of 3 or more floors for new
construction, but provides an exception for historic
buildings and limited alterations. The accessibility
requirement for alterations to existing structures states
that the cost of providing accessible facilities may not
exceed 20% of the cost of the overall improvements.
Pursuant to Section 8-602.2 -Alternative Accessibility
Provisions, if the historical significance or character
defining features of a historic building are threatened,
alternative provisions for access may be applied. The owner
and staff are currently evaluating whether the above
provisions apply.
Exterior Alterations
1. Mechanical Equipment on Roof:
The potential impacts
of HVAC units on the building’s roof will be
eliminated by use of a split system with fan coils on the
second and third floors. The units will be placed on a
small "catwalk" section of the roof located on the west
side of the building’s office section. The flytower
roof on the west side of the building’s theater
section will also incorporate split system HVAC units which
will be adequately screened by the existing parapet
wall.
2. Signage:
The submitted plans
do not show the proposed exterior signs, but their
locations are shown on the site plan, mezzanine plan, east
and north elevations, and the color renderings. PCR
considers the proposed marquee on Hermosa Avenue and the
marquee signs and banners on Thirteenth Street to be
appropriate in shape and design in relation to the existing
building. The marquees and banners will be fabricated using
brushed aluminum framing and will conform with the Building
Code.
Environmental Review
Pursuant to the CEQA
Guidelines, Article 19, Categorical Exemptions, the retrofit
and remodel of the Bijou Building is exempt from the
requirement for an environmental assessment. The relevant
Sections of CEQA that support this determination are Sections
15301(d) - Existing Facilities, and 15331 - Historical
Resource Restoration/Rehabilitation. Pursuant to Section
15301(d), the seismic retrofit is CEQA exempt because it
involves the repair and maintenance of an existing private
facility (a commercial building) to bring it into conformance
with seismic safety requirements with no expansion of the
existing use. Also, pursuant to Section 15331, any work
proposed beyond repair and maintenance for seismic safety
requirements is exempt if done to restore and rehabilitate a
historic resource in a manner consistent with the Secretary
of the Interior Standards for the Treatment of Historic
Properties.
Agendas / Minutes Menu
agenda
top of page
RESOLUTION
NO. 99-
A RESOLUTION OF THE
CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HERMOSA BEACH, CALIFORNIA,
APPROVING A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS FOR an
INTERIOR AND EXTERIOR remodel to a DESIGNATED HISTORIC
LANDMARK COMMERCIAL BUILDING AT 1221 HERMOSA
AVENUE
The City Council of the
City of Hermosa Beach does hereby resolve and order as
follows:
Section 1.
An application was
filed by CIM Group LLC owner of property at 1221 Hermosa
Avenue to approve a Certificate of Appropriateness for an
interior and exterior remodel to an existing commercial
building. The remodel will include seismic retrofit of the
building and renovation of the exterior elevations with no
floor area added.
Section 2.
The City Council conducted a duly noticed public meeting to
consider the application for a Certificate of Appropriateness
on September 28, 1999, at which testimony and evidence, both
written and oral, was presented to and considered by the City
Council.
Section 3.
Based on evidence received at the public hearing, the City
Council makes the following factual findings:
-
The project is
consistent with applicable general and specific plans,
and is in compliance with the use and development
requirements of the Zoning Ordinance.
-
The site is zoned
C-2, Restricted Commercial, and project and proposed use
complies with the development standards contained
therein.
-
-
Pursuant to the
City’s Historic Preservation Ordinance, the project
conforms with the review criteria and requirements set
forth by the Secretary of the Interior Standards for the
Treatment of Historic Properties.
-
The project is
Categorically Exempt pursuant to Section 15301,
Subsection (d) and Section 15331 with the findings that
the project consists of repair and maintenance of an
existing private structure (a commercial building) to
bring it into conformance with seismic safety
requirements with no expansion of the existing use, and
any work proposed beyond repair and maintenance for
seismic safety requirements is exempt if done to restore
and rehabilitate a historic resource in a manner
consistent with the Secretary of the Interior Standards
for the Treatment of Historic Properties.
Section 4.
Based on the foregoing, the City Council hereby approves the
subject Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the
following
Conditions of Approval
:
-
The development and
continued use of the property shall be in conformance with
submitted plans reviewed by the City Council
at their meeting of
September 28, 1999. Minor modifications to the plans shall
be reviewed and may be approved by the Community
Development Director.
-
Architectural
treatment including sign locations shall be as shown on
building elevations and site and floor plans. Any
modification shall require approval by the Community
Development Director.
-
The project shall
comply with the requirements of the Fire Department and the
Public Works Department.
-
-
Final building
plans/construction drawings including site, elevation,
floor plan, sections, details, signage, submitted for
building permit issuance shall be reviewed for consistency
with the plans approved by the City Council and the
conditions of this resolution, and approved by the
Community Development Director prior to the issuance of any
Building Permit.
-
The Certificate of
Appropriateness shall be recorded, and proof of recordation
shall be submitted to the Community Development
Department.
-
-
Each of the above
Conditions of Approval is separately enforced, and if one
of the Conditions of Approval is found to be invalid by a
court of law, all the other conditions shall remain valid
and enforceable.
-
-
Permittee shall
defend, indemnify and hold harmless the City, it agents,
officers, and employees from any claim, action, or
proceeding against the City or its agents, officers, or
employee to attack, set aside, void or annul this permit
approval, which action is brought within the applicable
time period of the State Government Code. The City shall
promptly notify the permittee of any claim, action, or
proceeding and the City shall cooperate fully in the
defense. If the City fails to promptly notify the permittee
of any claim, action or proceeding, or if the City fails to
cooperate fully in the defense, the permittee shall not
hereafter be responsible to defend, indemnify, or hold
harmless the City.
-
-
The permittee shall
reimburse the City for any court and attorney's fees which
the City may be required to pay as a result of any claim or
action brought against the City because of this grant.
Although the permittee is the real party in interest in an
action, the City may, at its sole discretion, participate
at its own expense in the defense of the action, but such
participation shall not relieve the permittee of any
obligation under this condition.
-
The subject property
shall be developed, maintained and operated in full
compliance with the conditions of this grant and any law,
statute, ordinance or other regulation applicable to any
development or activity on the subject property. Failure of
the permittee to cease any development or activity not in
full compliance shall be a violation of these
conditions.
Section 5.
Based on the foregoing, the City Council hereby approves a
Certificate of Appropriateness for an interior and exterior
remodel to a Designated Historic Landmark commercial building
at 1221 Hermosa Avenue.
PASSED, APPROVED,
and
ADOPTED
this 28th day of September 1999
Agendas / Minutes Menu
agenda
top of page